His first appointment after Yale University was as an undersecretary of the Interior Department. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Joseph Ejercity Estrada is the first film actor to become president of a country next to Ronald Reagan. While studying and finishing law school, he argued for and received an acquittal in 1912. [19], On October 20, 1943, the Philippine-Japanese Treaty of Alliance was signed by Claro M. Recto, who was appointed by Laurel as his Foreign Minister, and Japanese Ambassador to Philippines Sozyo Murata. Elected to the Senate in 1951, Laurel helped to persuade Ramon Magsaysay, then secretary of defense, to desert the Liberals and join the Nationalists. Through ODA, Japan has helped construct and improve infrastructure in the Philippines. Where did the Philippine government go when the Japanese attacked Manila? In 1915, he received his law degree from the University of the Philippines, and in 1919, a Master of Laws from the University of Santo Tomas. Diosdado Macapagal (December 30, 1961 December 30, 1965). 10. Despite the odds, Dr. Jose P. Laurel as President of this republic, did all he could and more to meet the problems of the time and to try to transcend them. Additional Services at PRC Dasmarias, Cavite & St Additional Testing Centers for the 2018 LEPT, ENGLISH - Q and A with Rationalizations (Part 2), ENGLISH - Q and A with Rationalizations (Part 1). These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Be 1. He was a versatile intellectua. Born as a native of Iba, Zambales, he was a military governor, and engineer. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. Sergio Osmea (August 1, 1944 May 28, 1946). The name Jose P. Laurel may whisper war and history to many millennial Filipinos. This was in an attempt to bring about political, social, and economic reforms to the Philippines. [27] He was later provisionally released in September 1946 after posting a 50,000 bail. This, in my opinion, is in consonance with the desire of His Holiness Pope Pius XI when he said: From the fact that the Roman Pontiff has entrusted to you and to your helpers a task of preaching Christian religion to pagan nations, you ought not to conclude that the role of native clergy is solely that of assisting missionaries in minor matters and in some sort of completing their work. He was later appointed Commissioner of Justice by the commander-in-chief of the Imperial Japanese Forces on January 26, 1942, but was effective three days prior. And when the judiciary mediates to allocate constitutional boundaries, it does not assert any superiority over the other departments; it does not in reality nullify or invalidate an act of the legislature, but only asserts the solemn and sacred obligation assigned to it by the Constitution to determine conflicting claims of authority under the Constitution and to establish for the parties in an actual controversy the rights which that instrument secures and guarantees to them.[10]. At the same time, the Court still asserted that the right to due process of law must be observed, and enumerated the "cardinal primary rights" that must be respected in administrative proceedings. It envisions itself to be the center for integral faith formation, academic excellence and servant - leadership for the members of the school community. There is one eternal God, Creator, and Sustainer of the universe. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. Get the news that matters from one of the leading news sites in the Philippines, Xian Gaza, nang-tsismis ukol sa ex-husband ni Cristine Reyes, Jasmine Curtis-Smith reacts to baby Dahlia's bathroom singing: Little singer like mama, Cristy Fermin kay Alden Richards: "Marunong siyang rumespeto lalo na sa mga press people", Glimpses of Richard Gutierrez, Sarah Lahbatis son Zions birthday party go viral, Anne Curtis, balik-training para sa bagong pelikula: "Back to the blade refresher", Amazing facts about special power of attorney, Joven Hernando: who is he, is he real, wiki, quotes, history, Our lady of Fatima University courses, admission, tuition fee, address (2020), Anime quotes about love and pain that will give you diverse emotions, Interesting facts about Ahn Jae Hyun's wife, Twice members profile: names, religion, boyfriends, latest news, How to Pasaload Smart: to Globe, to TNT, to Smart, prepaid, postpaid, Citibank credit card: application, benefits and rewards, Toni Fowler, naghanda ng Despedida party para sa kanyang mommy, Vice Ganda, pinakalma ang fans matapos syang ma-ospital: All good.Healthy si Meme, Pauleen Luna gives glimpse of Vic Sottos heartwarming birthday dinner, Tyronia Fowler, emosyonal na nagbigay ng mensahe sa kanyang lola na pabalik na sa Amerika. Following the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, Hawaii (December 1941), and the subsequent Japanese assault on the Philippines, Laurel stayed in Manila; President Manuel Quezon had escaped, first to the Bataan Peninsula and then to the United States. [3] He received his law degree from the University of the Philippines College of Law in 1915, where he studied under Dean George A. Malcolm, whom he would later succeed at the Supreme Court of the Philippines. Erap para sa mahirap is his popular slogan. Just clear tips and lifehacks for every day. Jos P. Laurel's presidency is controversial. Initiated a rehabilitation on Boracay, jump-started efforts to clean Manila Bay and Laguna Lake and got Canada to take back its illegal garbage stranded in the Philippines. [citation needed] He took the oath of office on October 14, 1943, at the Legislative Building (now the National Museum of Fine Arts) in Manila. He was officially the government's caretaker during the Japanese occupation of World War II. The Japanese government refused the offer. One redeeming feature was that no conscription was envisioned.[17]. [16], Laurel ran for president as a nominee of the Nacionalista Party against Elpidio Quirino in 1949 but lost in what future Foreign Affairs Secretary Carlos P. Romulo and Marvin M. Gray considered as the dirtiest election in Philippine electoral history. Thank you so much. She was 14 back when she became familiar, moved and lived in the Malacanang Palace as the daughter of the president. 139, (1936). 30 was issued the next day, declaring the existence of a state of war between the Philippines and the United States and the United Kingdom. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". He received an LL.B. and the same time to encourage vocations to religious and sacerdotal life. Become Premium to read the whole document. Jos P. Laurel, in full Jos Paciano Laurel, (born March 9, 1891, Tanauan, Luzon, Philippinesdied November 6, 1959, Manila), Filipino lawyer, politician, and jurist, who served as president of the Philippines (1943-45) during the Japanese occupation during World War II. Angara v. Electoral Commission, 63 Phil. As the Father of National Language (Ama ng Wikang Pambansa in Tagalog), Manuel Luis Quezon is Philippine president known to have died of a common man's disease, tuberculosis in his last few days in Saranac Lake, New York according to a wiki biography. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. He envisioned his fellow countrymen having assertive nationalism, which is commonly known as Filipinism. On November 6, 1959, at 1:00 in the morning, he died at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Manila,[30] from a massive heart attack and cerebral hemorrhage. Laurel was among the Commonwealth officials instructed by the Japanese Imperial Army to form a provisional government when they invaded and occupied the country. Since the administration of President Diosdado Macapagal (19611965), Laurel has been officially recognized by later administrations as a former president of the Philippines. Shortly after the inauguration of the Second Philippine Republic, President Laurel, together with cabinet Ministers Recto and Paredes flew to Tokyo to attend the Greater East Asia Conference which was an international summit held in Tokyo, Japan from November 5 6, 1943, in which Japan hosted the heads of state of various component members of the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere. A well renowned country lawyer in his time, Carlos P. Garcia was a critically acclaimed poet, teacher and self-proclaimed guerilla leader. 1. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. He was indeed one of the best military and political tactician and brightest president who ever lived to retain the longest reign using his power and knowhow in Philippine laws as a lawyer. 1943: President Jose P. Laurel was confined in the Philippine General Hospital after an assassination attempt against him the day before in the Wack-Wack golf course in Mandaluyong. [14], However, in his 1953 memoirs, Laurel would admit that Lizardo, by then one of his bodyguards who had pledged to give his life for him, was indeed the would-be-assassin. His governance had been through to numerous controversies and characterized by impeachments, slow economic growth and was later on convicted guilty of plunder case. It does not store any personal data. He was the chief-of-staff of the Armed Forces of the Philippines during Cory's regime before he became president. During his work for the Code Committee, he was introduced to its head, Thomas A. In July 1946 he was charged with dozens of counts of treason, but he never stood trial; he shared in a general amnesty declared by President Manuel Roxas in April 1948. He also headed the Philippine BAnking Corporation up to the day of his death. initiated an unprecedented scale of military upgrade. Contributions and Achievements of Fidel V. Ramos, Joseph Estrada (June 30, 1998 January 20, 2001). )), Presidents of the Philippines and their Contributions, Cedric KYLE Y. Yabut - BSCE 1A - Reaction NO, Yabut, Cedric KYLE Y. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. How to Download Exam Reviewers (PDF format), first (and only) president of the First Republic (Malolo Republic), signed the Pact of Biak-na-Bato, creating a truce between the Spanish and Philippine revolutionaries, known as the President of the Revolutionary Government, led the Philippines in the Spanish-Philippine War and the American-Philippine War, youngest president, taking office at age 28, longest-lived president, passing away at 94, first Senate president elected as President of the Philippines, first president elected through a national election, initiated womens suffrage in the Philippines during the Commonwealth, approved Tagalog/Filipino as the national language of the Philippines, a province, a city, a bridge and a university in Manila are named after him, his body lies within the special monument on Quezon Memorial Circle, accepted some 1300 jewish refugees, thus saving their lives from the "holocaust", since the early 1960s, Laurel considered a legitimate president of the Philippines, organized KALIBAPI (Kapisanan sa Paglilingkod sa Bagong Pilipinas, or Association for Service to the New Philippines), a provisional government during Japanese occupation, declared Martial Law and war between the Philippines and the U.S./United Kingdom in 1944, with his family, established the Lyceum of the Philippines, became president at 65, making him the oldest person to hold office, joined with U.S. Gen. Douglas McArthur in Leyte on October 20, 1944 to begin restoration of Philippine freedom after Japanese occupation, Philippine National Bank was rehabilitated and the country joined the International Monetary Fund during his presidency, Bell Trade Act was approved by the U.S. Congress during his presidency, inaugurated as the first president of the new Republic after World War II, reconstruction from war damage and life without foreign rule began during his presidency, under his term, the Philippine Rehabilitation Act and Philippine Trade Act laws were accepted by Congress, Hukbalahap guerrilla movement active during his presidency, created Integrity Board to monitor graft and corruption, Quezon City became capital of the Philippines in 1948, Hukbalahap movement quelled during his presidency, chairman of the Committee on Guerilla Affairs, first president sworn into office wearing Barong Tagalog during inauguration, presidency referred to as the Philippines' "Golden Years" for its lack of corruption, Philippines was ranked second in Asias clean and well-governed countries during his presidency, established National Resettlement and Rehabilitation Administration (NARRA) among other agrarian reforms, known for Filipino First Policy, which favored Filipino businesses over foreign investors, established the Austerity Program focusing on Filipino trade and commerce, known as the Prince of Visayan Poets and the Bard from Bohol, cultural arts was revived during his term, was the first president to have his remains buried at the Libingan ng mga Bayani, established the first Land Reform Law, allowing for the purchase of private farmland to be distributed in inexpensive, small lots to the landless, placed the Philippine peso on the currency exchange market, declared June 12, 1898 to be Philippines Independence Day, before and during his first term,the Philippines was the second largest economy in Asia, behind only Japan, increased the size of Philippine military and armed forces, by 1980 the Philippine GNP was four times greater than 1972, by 1986 the Philippines was one of the most indebted countries in Asia, built more schools, roads, bridges, hospitals, and other infrastructure than all former presidents combined (note: he was the longest serving president), first woman to be president of the Philippines or any Asian country, abolished the 1973 Marcos Constitution and ushered in the new Constitution of the Philippines, reorganized the structure of the executive branch of government, signed the Family Code of 1987, a major civil law reform, and 1191 Local Government Code, which reorganized the structure of the executive branch of government, initiated charitable and social activities helping the poor and the needy, named Woman of the Year in 1986 by Time magazine, on the new 500-peso bill together with her husband Benigno Aquino, Received honors and awards including: 100 Women Who Shaped World History, 20 Most Influential Asians of the 20th Century, 65 Great Asian Heroes, J. William Fulbright Prize for International Understanding, presided over celebrations of Philippine Independence Centennial in 1998, received British Knighthood from the United Kingdom by Queen Elizabeth II (Knight Grand Cross of the Order of St. Michael and St. George), hosted the fourth Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation Leader's Summit in the Philippines in 1996, Philippine Stock Exchange became an international favorite during his presidency, death penalty reinstated while he was in office, signed peace agreement with the rebel Moro National Liberation Front, during his presidency Moro Islamic Liberation Front headquarters and camps were captured, joined other leaders and politicians to try to amend the 1987 Constitution, cited as one of the Three Outstanding Senators in 1989, among the Magnificent 12 who voted to terminate the agreement that allows for U.S. control of Clark Airbase and Subic Naval Base, first and only female vice-president of the Philippines so far, first president to take oath outside Luzon, former Economics professor at the Ateneo de Manila University, where current president Benigno Aquino III was one of her students, ex-classmate of former U.S. President Bill Clinton at Georgetown Universitys Walsh School of Foreign Service, where she maintained Deans list status, oversaw higher economic growth than the past three presidents before her, peso became the best-performing currency of the year in Asia in 2007, initiated K-12 education in the Philippines, in 2013, the Philippines wins its first investment-grade credit rating from Fitch Ratings, similar upgrades from other credit rating agencies Moodys and Standard and Poors follow later that year, changed the Philippines' reputation as "the sick man of Asia" to "brightest spot in Asia", oversaw higher economic growth thanhis predecessors, signed a landmark law mandating the state provide free contraceptives to poor couples and teach sex education in schools, filed a suit at a UN-linked international arbitration tribunal in the Hague to invalidate China's claim of Philippine claimed territories in the West Philippine Sea. Gentlemen: I am very happy to be able to administer your oath of office this morning. 587. degree in 1915 from the University of the Philippines, a D.C.L. He authored several leading cases still analyzed to this day that defined the parameters of the branches of government as well as their powers. On the other hand, guerrilla activities and Japanese retaliatory measures brought the peace and order situation to a difficult point. Prof Ed Reviewer: 50 Questions with Answers Part 1, General Education Reviewer Part 1: 50 Questions with Answers, Prof Ed Reviewer: 50 Questions with Answers Part 2, 2018 English Reviewer: 130 Questions with Answers, 2018 Social Science Reviewer 1: 50 Items with Answer Key and Rationalization, ROOM ASSIGNMENT: March 2018 LET Teachers Board Exam. Thank you. Jose P. Laurel remains to be one of the most controversial presidents in the Philippines that will be remembered for his patriotic ways of governing his country. He is the first and only non-Catholic (protestant) president of the Philippines. 726 (1940) was a seemingly innocuous case involving a challenge raised by a private citizen to a traffic regulation banning kalesas from Manila streets during certain afternoon hours. He died on a plane crash on Dec. 1957, boarding the presidential plane named Mt. When Magsaysay became president, Laurel headed an economic mission that in 1955 negotiated an agreement to improve economic relations with the United States. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Without in any way presuming to invade an ecclesiastical jurisdiction in Philippines, it is my honest belief that the spread of Catholicism among our non-Christian brethren and consequently increase of its followers in this country. Served first as the vice president of Manuel Roxas in his time and assumed to become the next leader and Philippine president when the latter died in 1948. [3][2], During his retirement, Laurel resided in a 1957 3-story, 7-bedroom mansion in Mandaluyong, Rizal, dubbed "Villa Pacencia" after Laurel's wife. He advocated for education for the Filipinos, and their economic progress on books such as Education for Filipinos: Address Delivered at the Commencement Exercises Manila: University of the East, 1952. He had the most controversial terms of all Philippine presidents especially during his time when he declared and used Martial Law to remain in tenure as the highest government official in the country. Below are the questions/requirement: Your. His father had been an official in the revolutionary government of Emilio Aguinaldo and a signatory to the 1899 Malolos Constitution. His political philosophy is deeply rooted in his love and belief in his country. Recto. He was born on March 9, 1891, in Tanauan, Batangas. Calalang v. Williams, 70 Phil. The Filipino senator, and the eminent president of the Japanese-sponsored Republic of the Philippines, proved to be a true patriot. He married Pacencia Hidalgo on April 9, 1911. During his teenage days, he was indicted for attempted murder which he later received an acquittal. He is the only Philippine president I saw who had no idiot board and "codigo" of his speech during SONA. Ramon Magsaysay (December 30, 1953 March 17, 1957). The Allied Forces' message now had a telling effect: Japan unconditionally surrendered to the Allied Powers on August 15, 1945. Omissions? He was the first ousted president due to excessive and oppressive use of power and was the first to voluntarily flee out of office because of EDSA People Power. International Journal of Social Science and Humanities Research ISSN 2348-3164 (online) Vol. Real name is Simeon Benigno Aquino III a.k.a. Laurel was appointed by President Manuel L. Quezon as a member of the Moral Code Committee in 1939 and as member of the Code Committee in 1940. In 1925, Laurel was elected to the Philippine Senate and later appointed an associate justice of the Supreme Court in 1936. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Street, a future Supreme Court Justice who would be a mentor to the young Laurel. Jos Paciano Laurel y Garca CCLH, KGCR (March 9, 1891 - November 6, 1959) was a Filipino politician, lawyer, and judge, who served as the president of the Japanese-occupied Second Philippine Republic, a puppet state during World War II, from 1943 to 1945. Jose Laurel survived three gunshot wounds. Popularly known as PNoy, he is the son of the first female Philippine president and of Asia Corazon Cojuangco Aquino. Which hypothesis of Krashens Monitor Model proposes that when learners are exposed to grammatical features a little beyo Hi everyone, if you want to download a pdf file of this, you can download it for free HERE . The projected measure can be achieved without in the least prejudicing interests, or sacrificing the creed or doctrines of the Roman Catholic Church. 2 What role did the Philippine Executive Commission play during the Japanese occupation? Two days later, the Soviet Union declared war against Japan and invaded Manchuria. The original Rizal which was opposed by the Catholic church, since it impaired their religious freedom, was later revised. Not by words but by deeds. Please help me, I think online based learning is not for me :(( I'm struggling in this questions below. As he was well known to the Japanese as a critic of US rule, as well as having demonstrated a willingness to serve under the Japanese Military Administration, he held a series of high posts in 19421943. Ferdinand Marcos (December 30, 1965 February 25, 1986). a. Thank you and God bless. Laurel, the first Chancellor of the National Teachers College, later on founded the Lyceum of the Philippines and served as its president. JOSE P. LAUREL 1943-1945--- Jos P. Laurel's presidency is controversial. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". Laurel was a member of the Philippine fraternity Upsilon Sigma Phi. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Laurel was also named as chairman of the Senate Committee on Education, which he held when he sponsored in 1955 a bill that would make Jos Rizal's two novels, Noli Me Tngere and El filibusterismo, as compulsory readings in all universities and colleges. Application Deadline for the March 2018 LET extended. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. He retired from public life in 1957. [11], While an associate justice, Laurel also held other appointive posts. . [28], Laurel garnered more than 2 million votes and was elected to the Senate as the top vote getter in 1951, under the Nacionalista Party. Moreover foreign missionaries, on account of their imperfect knowledge of Filipino language, are frequently prevented from expressing themselves fully and having themselves clearly understood, as a result of which, force and efficacy of their teachings are greatly weakened. Jose P. Laurel was the president of the Second Philippine Republic, popularly known as the Japanese puppet state. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The heated disputes included the law that was sponsored by Sen. Jose P. Laurel. II of the Jose P. Laurel Memorial Series by the Lyceum Press. President Jose P. Laurel is remembered for his timely responses in dealing with food shortage and general dissent. Manuel L. Quezon (November 15, 1935 August 1, 1944). Manuel Roxas (May 28, 1946 April 15, 1948). [3] His time as associate justice ended on February 5, 1942. He advocated for education for the Filipinos, and their economic progress on books such as Education for Filipinos: Address Delivered at the Commencement Exercises - Manila: University of the East, 1952. [3], While a teen, Laurel was indicted for attempted murder when he almost killed a rival suitor of the girl he stole a kiss from with a fan knife. What is the contribution of Jose P Laurel in the Philippines? It will also be a source of genuine satisfaction and lasting inspiration for Filipino people to see a Filipino at the head of the Catholic Church in Philippines, a Filipino priest in every parish and a Filipino missionary in every remote corner of the country. Teaching is not your passion ~ if teaching is not your passion, it will be hard for you to understand the very nature of it. Jose P. Laurel children were nine, and they included 6 sons and 3 daughters. [17], Beginning in March 1945, President Laurel, together with his family, Camilo Osas, Benigno Aquino Sr., Gen. Mateo M. Capinpin, and Jorge B. Vargas evacuated to Baguio. On November 16, 1945, they were transferred to Sugamo Prison. This is a Premium document. He is also known for being the first president of the Philippines under the First Republic known in Philippine history back then as the Malolos Republic. In 1907, he finished the intermediate grades at Manila public schools. The Permanent Court of Arbitration awarded a landmark victory to the Philippines, it has won on almost all of its arguments against China, instigated the foreign policy shift, from being a pro - US ally, to a more independent stance (or a pro - China stance), Bloody war on drugs. Republic of the Philippines during World War, the local Japanese community before World War II, he, was able to establish close relationships, politics and was eventually elected Senator of, normal relations with Japan. So you may copy or you can download a doc file. When President Manuel Quezon had escaped following Japanese invasion of the Philippines (1941-1942), Laurel offered his services to the intruders. After studying law at the University of the Philippines, near Manila, Roxas began his political career in 1917 as a member of the municipal council of Capiz (renamed Roxas in 1949). Please answer this for me. Controversially dubbed by some as the Philippine president who sold the Philippines independence, Gen. Emilio Aguinaldo's symbolic face can be found in the old 5-peso bill which is no longer used in the Philippines. Q: Contribution of Jose P. Laurel in Science, Technology and Society. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Laurel was later awarded a scholarship at Yale Law School, where he obtained his J.S.D. On December 10, 1941, then-Associate Justice Laurel was appointed by President Manuel L. Quezon as acting Secretary of Justice. His father served in the cabinet of Emilio Aguinaldo in the late 1890s. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. With many firsts under his biography according to wikipedia, below is a list. Prices of essential commodities rose to unprecedented heights. Problem 6-12 (AICPA Adapted) On December 31, 2020, On January 1, 2020, Mill Company sold a building and received as consideration 1,000,000 cash and a 4,000,000 noninterest bearing note due on January 1, 2023. Mindanao State University - Iligan Institute of Technology, The Presidency of Jose P. Laurel- Gallardo.pdf. Philippine Presidents: Their Achievements and Contributions, Licensure Examination For Teachers LET Reviewer, Civil Servie Exam Review Guides & Materials, Be A DOST-SEI Scholarship Program Recipient, How To Become An Air Traffic Controller In The Philippines, Be A Member Of The Philippine National Police, Become A Drug Enforcement Officer At PDEA. Certainly, it will foster development of national clergy of superior stamp and it will serve as an ideal incentive for Filipino clergy to work to the highest degree of perfection 1 . He was the senator of the Third Republic and the author of Rizal Law, and at the same time was the negotiator of the Laurel Langley Trade agreement. Gloria Macapagal Arroyo (January 20, 2001 June 30, 2010). Be the first to get hottest news from our Editor-in-Chief, Check your email and confirm your subscription. Contributions and Achievements of Jose P. Laurel: Jose P. Laurel is the only Philippine president who served the three branches of government - he became a senator-congressman, associate justice, and president Since the early 1960s, Laurel was recognized as a legitimate president of the Philippines We do not claim ownership of the available reviewers. June 22, 1944 Tags: Jose P. Laurel, messages 'The Nation Must Fall Back on Science' Remarks on the occasion of the induction into office of the additional members of the Council of Scientists, Malacanan, June 22, 1944. Furthermore, we do not make any warranty with regards to reliability and accuracy of the information. In that post, he would frequently clash with the American Governor-General Leonard Wood, and eventually, in 1923, resign from his position together with other Cabinet members in protest of Wood's administration. [14] Another suspect, a former boxer named Feliciano Lizardo, was presented for identification by the Japanese to Laurel at the latter's hospital bed, but Laurel then professed unclear memory.