arthur labinjo hughes court transcript

Dr Dixon said Arthur was subjected to 'dehumanising and humiliating' treatment and appeared to want an 'end to his suffering' by calling out for his grandmother and uncle. He said he had wanted to "shock" rather than "hurt" his son, but that he "probably" hit him harder than intended. Ms Tustin later said: "I don't even remember speaking to them [the police], I was tired. The Independent Office of Police Conduct (IOPC) is set to publish a report into West Midlands Police's contact with the case in due course but said it "found no indication any individual behaved in a manner that justified disciplinary proceedings". A trial today heard how 200 audio files of Arthur recorded by Tustin showed how he was subjected to 'very significant ill-treatment'. I thought: 'He's knocked him f****** self out what am I going to do'. He died in hospital the next day with a post-mortem examination giving a cause of death as a "head trauma inflicted on him by an adult" consistent with being "vigorously shaken and his head banged repeatedly against a hard surface". They have also previously heard audio clips Tustin recorded of Arthur sobbing while allegedly being abused. Despite his comments, no action was taken and Hughes was believed by staff when he told them the youngster was "doing grand" during a call in lockdown. The Attorney General acts independently of government when deciding on Unduly Lenient Sentences, also known as acting as guardian of the public interest. Mr Justice Wall referred to audio and video files Tustin had recorded of Arthur "crying, calling out for his grandparents and uncles, hitting himself in a way which anyone would recognise as a cry for help from a deeply unhappy child, and saying that nobody loved him and that he was hungry and thirsty". View our online Press Pack. 7 most harrowing pieces of evidence that snared killer dad and stepmum over tragic Arthur Labinjo-Hughes' death. There's nothing under the floor, it's just concrete. They give the impression of a forlorn little boy in tears. On the day Arthur collapsed, his dad had messaged: Put him outside, put him out with the rubbish.. Dont worry we wont send you spam or share your email address with anyone. The court heard how one witness claimed Arthur was 'too weak' to even hold a glass of water to his mouth on the day before he collapsed. "The injuries sustained by him were extensive and devastating," he added. The worst situation.". As always you can unsubscribe at any time. The haunting clips were punctuated in evidence by vile text exchanges between Tustin and Hughes. Find out about the Energy Bills Support Scheme, Cornwall and West Devon mining landscape: review of SOUV, Remuneration information of the CDEI advisory board. Medics said this was consistent with being "vigorously shaken and his head banged repeatedly against a hard surface". However, in court she told how Arthur was already unconscious after the crack - adding that Arthur hit out at her some moments previously, in a separate incident. No further action was taken and the injury was put down to "boisterous play" with his step-siblings. Emma Tustin is accused of fatally shaking and hitting Arthur Labinjo-Hughes at her home in Solihull in June 2020. I was frightened. Even if just half of the 130 bruises on Arthur's body were the result of abuse, it would still be a mark for every day he spent being terrorised by Tustin and Hughes during lockdown. A DAD talked about digging his six-year-old son's grave and threatened to "end him" just two days before murdering him, a court heard today. Arthur Labinjo Hughes was found with 125 areas of bruising on his body after dying from unsurvivable brain injuries in June 2020. "If you want to make suggestions, I can't stop you doing that but that's not the case . He kind of couldn't grasp it. I understand how distressing the public have found this case, but it is my job to decide if a sentence appears to be unduly lenient based on the facts of the case. Tustin added: "He banged his head three or four times. He was allegedly beaten, dragged by the scruff of the neck and made to stand for 14 hours a day in cruelty 'designed to terrorise', say prosecutors. He's knocked himself out, please get back'.". To inquire about a licence to reproduce material, visit our Syndication site. Earlier, Prime Minister Boris Johnson said he would leave "no stone unturned" to find out what went wrong. This is an extremely upsetting and disturbing case, involving a clearly vulnerable young child. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. It's been a harrowing trial for all of them. Around two weeks before Arthurs death, Tustin recorded herself commanding Arthur to put his arms by his side. During one audio clip recorded during the period when Arthur was being forced to stand like a statue near the front door for hour after hour, Tustin was heard loudly repeating do it, do it. I don't feel like I'm a bad dad.". An expert suggested he was given at least 34 grams of salt - equivalent to six teaspoons - leading to hospital readings which were 'off the scale'. The cross-examination of Tustin continued at Coventry Crown Court on Monday after the weekend break. The trial heard Arthur had been poisoned with salt, subjected to regular beatings, denied food and drink and made to stand for hours alone in the hallway. Towards the end of the distressing clip, little Arthur edges out of the room while limping on his bruised legs. Or by navigating to the user icon in the top right. Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. He would get a smack more than he should. After his death, doctors found 130 bruises on his skeletal body where he had suffered 93 different areas of injury. Dr Dixon said: 'The idea of standing for more than 13 hours would seem interminable. She denies murder and two counts of child cruelty. Emma Tustin, 32, was convicted of the murder of her 6-year-old stepson, Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. Emma Tustin and Thomas Hughes grossly abused their position of trust and subjected an innocent child, who they should have been protecting to continued emotional and physical abuse. Mr Hankin said: "This interview was three days after the event, that you are describing a very memorable event and you are emphasising the crack [you heard]. He had been placed in his dad's care after his mum Olivia Labinjo-Halcrow, 26, was jailed for 18 years for stabbing her boyfriend to death. There's more to come, because further investigations will determine whether opportunities were missed to intervene and possibly save Arthur. She had already taken a picture of stricken Arthur lying in a hallway after inflicting the fatal blow. His pyjamas - the same onesie he had been in for the fifth day in a row - appear to be hanging off him. Arthur was forced to stand alone in a hallway for up to 14 hours a day and deprived of food and water. The levels were still the same seven hours after he was taken to hospital - suggesting he had consumed so much salt his stomach couldn't absorb it all at once. An inside look at the housing crisis. Hughes claimed he was "devoted" to his son, but something had "gone wrong" and his son had "paid the price", prosecutors said. "His death has turned the colour of our lives into a perpetual grey," she continued. West Midlands Police has vowed to spend more money on protecting at-risk children after it faced fresh criticism in a new report into the Arthur Labinjo-Hughes tragedy. Thomas Hughes, 29, sent. The piece of paper - titled "Chair list" - included a one hour stint on a pink naughty chair if Arthur was "rude to mummy bear" [Tustin]. 679215 Registered office: 1 London Bridge Street, London, SE1 9GF. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. The government has launched a national review and local inspection following the murder of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. Hughes explained that Tustin took numerous "recordings" of Arthur to "cover her own back" should he go to school and claim she had hit him, the court heard. He added: "Together they denigrated and debased him, they dehumanised him.". Meanwhile, his dad and stepmum cooled down with ice cream in a hot tub outside. Tustin answered: I did get it wrong, very wrong. This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. Bruising to Arthur Labinjo-Hughes' back was "ignored" by social services, the chair of the Government's safeguarding review has told MPs. She and Hughes are accused of multiple counts of child cruelty, after forcing Arthur to endure "systematic, cruel behaviour" of "physical and psychological" abuse in the weeks before his death. You can change your cookie settings at any time. Arthurs visible injuries, his miserable physical condition and obvious despair provided each defendant with a daily reminder of the lengths to which the other would go to cause him harm.. Thomas Hughes told police he should have treated the six-year-old 'like a child rather than a prisoner', Our free email updates are the best way to get headlines direct to your inbox, The father of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes told detectives of the moment his son looked at him and said: "I'm in danger with you.". At that point, Mr Justice Mark Wall interjected and asked Tustin: I just want to be clear that Ive understood this. This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. She said: 'The description is not a plausible description of the mechanisms of the force that would be required to generate those injuries.'. Peter Halcrow, the boy's maternal grandfather, claimed that warnings from other family members were "not acted on" by police or social services. Stepmum Tustin has been jailed for a minimum of 29 years for murdering . Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? He loved reading and his favourite story was The Snail and the Whale. Something went wrong, please try again later. We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. So I hit him with it, the bottom of it. In one she writes: "Backchatting me for joke threw himself on the floor shouting abuse. VideoThe world's most endangered jobs. She said she moved Arthur to the sofa and tried to give him some water which she thought he was drinking until it 'came back up' with some food around 30 seconds later. Mother-of-two Tustin allegedly killed Arthur using 'very severe force' while she was alone with him at her council house near Solihull, West Midlands. On Thursday, dad Thomas Hughes and stepmother Emma Tustin were convicted after . "Life as I know it will never exist again," Olivia Labinjo-Halcrow's statement said. Arthur also had 25 sites of bruising on his scalp, face, and neck that raised serious concerns about non-accidental injury. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. Drivers warned of major new law coming into effect on November 15, Bullet-riddled Golf probed at hospital as A&E 'locked down' after man shot a mile away, West Midlands Police said officers believed a 'targeted attack' had taken place on a residential street around a mile away from Heartlands Hospital, Michelle Heaton shares sad photo after celebrating two years of sobriety, The Liberty X singer shared a throwback photo to the last day she drank alcohol, MasterChef Australia judge Jock Zonfrillo dies as Jamie Oliver and Gordon Ramsay lead tributes, Gordon Ramsay and Jamie Oliver are among the famous names to have paid tribute to the 46-year-old presenter, Sister sprayed brother with chili and vinegar concoction in long-running family feud, She attacked him after a chance meeting in the street and then tried to spray him again, hoping he would be peering through his letterbox, Teenage boy 'missing in river' and four friends pulled from water, Major search of Lechlade-on-Thames river under way to find boy, Birmingham street shooting live as bullet-riddled Golf probed at Heartlands Hospital, Shots were fired on Shaw Hill Road in Washwood Heath yesterday evening (April 30), 10 major money changes in May including DWP tax credits and Tesco deliveries, Major announcements are coming up in May and they may affect your wallet, Coronation uproar as Birmingham residents react to allegiance pledge with everyone saying same thing, Around Birmingham, residents hit out at King Charles' allegiance pledge request, 14 Netflix shows people love that you've probably never heard of, These Netflix original series have received a perfect score on the Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer, Lidl makes major change at 30 stores ahead of nationwide roll-out, Lidl is following supermarkets like Aldi who have already trialled the technology, Everton sent Aston Villa warning ahead of key relegation clash, Aston Villa were relegated in 2015-16 under Tim Sherwood and Remi Garde - defender Micah Richards was a member of that squad, Aston Villa loan latest as Wesley and Sanson impress, Archer and Louie Barry fight for promotion, A run through Aston Villas loan players as it comes down to the business end of the season with players fighting for promotion and against relegation, Birmingham street shooting live as bullet-riddled Golf probed at hospital, Jailed in April - The latest criminals sent to prison from Birmingham and beyond, Our April 2023 roundup features a number of killers and serious sex offenders who have been locked up, Celebrity deaths 2023 all the stars who have died in April, Barry Humphries, Len Goodman and S Club 7's Paul Cattermole are among those who died this month, 'I suffered horror symptoms for 8 years before docs diagnosed me - here's what I want people to know', Hannah was diagnosed with relapsing MS meaning she endures episodes of new or worsening symptoms - she wants to raise awareness of the often misunderstood condition, Lee Bowyer tipped for Premier League job after Birmingham City sack, Birmingham City parted company with Lee Bowyer at the end of last season and he was replaced by John Eustace - he has been tipped to return to Leeds United, England's stunning smallest city named one of best places to live that's dream day out, Tiny countryside city off M5 with charming pubs and restaurants has only 12,000 residents, Tower crane installed by 'spider men' next to Birmingham Town Hall, The 1.2 billion Paradise project in Birmingham city centre has reached another milestone with a 50-metre tower crane arriving to build Three Chamberlain Square, Six household appliances that can cost 450-a-year to run - full list, Fridges, freezers, and washing machines are all becoming significantly more expensive to run. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast . Arthur Labinjo-Hughes can finally be laid to rest after his father Thomas agreed to release the six-year-old's body for burial. Hughes was convicted of the boy's manslaughter. Chillingly, he was so weak from the poisoning that he couldn't even put up a fight against her when she battered him. Emma Tustin was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 29 years, and Thomas Hughes was sentenced to 21 years imprisonment. In April 2020, it emerged children's social services and police were alerted by his grandmother to concerns about Arthur's care. I have carefully considered the details of this case, and I have decided to refer the sentences to the Court of Appeal as I believe them to be too low. Arthur's behaviour issues because of lockdown, he took the brunt of my frustrations. The tragic youngster was subjected to a "campaign of cruelty" before his death that matched the medical definition of child torture, it is said. Thomas Hughes, Arthur Labinjo-Hughes and Emma Tustin. Day after day, taking multiple forms. A date for the hearing at the Court of Appeal is yet to be set. A serious case review has now been launched into the shortcomings - including that Tustin was already known to childrens services over previous concerns of domestic violence. To inquire about a licence to reproduce material, visit our Syndication site. I did not lie.. Other penalties included 20 minutes for a "poor attitude", 40 minutes for being "naughty", ten minutes for "weeing on toilet seat" and ten minutes for "talking like a baby". "This sentencing marks the end of the first stage in achieving some sort of justice for Arthur.". Sign up here. ", He also cried in one clip: "Daddy's going to throw me out the window, daddy's going to throw me out the window, daddy's going to throw me out of the window.". Tustin says: "Basically he's threw himself on the floor, he's headbutted the floor. Caroline Johnson, a Conservative MP on the Commons . Arthur Labinjo Hughes died from unsurvivable brain injuries. The shameless mum blamed the youngster for his own injuries - claiming he "headbutted the floor on all fours". Is climate change killing Australian wine? Here are the seven most harrowing pieces of evidence to come out at trial. Robert Grnling. Thomas Hughes did apologise via his lawyer, but it's hard to believe that will carry much weight with the family members who were present in court, many of whom were in tears. In one message, Hughes threatened to 'take his jaw off his shoulders' and told Tustin: 'Just gag him or something.
Elizabeth Bowes Gregory College, Direct Attachment Vs Remote Attachment Ansys, Nicole Kidman Naples Fl, Heartbroken Stephanie Hurt Wife Of Charles Hurt, University Of Miami Food Truck Schedule, Articles A